Search

Case Study: Winning With Strategic planning for multi-location distributors

By buildingmaterial | April 23, 2025

In the building materials industry, scaling to multiple branches introduces new levels of complexity—across operations, logistics, inventory, and leadership. Many distributors struggle with consistency, profitability, and coordination as they expand. But those that succeed have one thing in common:

👉 A disciplined, forward-looking strategic planning process tailored to multi-location growth.

This case study explores how IronGate Supply, a mid-sized building materials distributor, leveraged strategic planning to transform from a scattered group of branches into a high-performing, unified distribution network—without losing local market responsiveness.

🏢 Company Snapshot: IronGate Supply

Headquarters: Kansas City, MO

Locations: 9 branches across the Midwest

Focus: Framing lumber, engineered wood, roofing, siding, fasteners, and specialty building products

Challenge: Inconsistent performance across locations, siloed decision-making, and operational inefficiencies during rapid growth

🎯 The Goal: Create an Integrated, Scalable Strategic Plan

Leadership set out to answer a big question:

“How do we scale smart—without becoming a disconnected group of branches operating on instinct instead of strategy?”

Their objective was clear: Unify the company with a shared vision, clear performance metrics, and branch-level accountability—while enabling local flexibility.

✅ Step 1: Launch a Cross-Branch Strategic Planning Process

The Problem: Strategy was historically set by the executive team alone, with limited buy-in or execution at the branch level.

What They Did:

Held a two-day strategic planning retreat with executives, branch managers, and key department heads

Identified shared company-wide goals: margin expansion, on-time delivery, and product line diversification

Set branch-level strategic themes aligned with corporate priorities

Result:

🎯 Branches had clear goals and could see how their success impacted the entire company.

✅ Step 2: Introduce Shared KPIs Across All Locations

The Problem: Branches were measuring different things—or nothing at all.

What They Did:

Rolled out a core set of performance metrics across all locations:

Gross margin %

Inventory turns

Order fill rate

Customer satisfaction (NPS)

Cost per delivery

Tracked progress monthly via a shared dashboard

Result:

📊 Visibility drove accountability—and healthy competition among branches.

✅ Step 3: Align Leadership Incentives With Strategic Goals

The Problem: Some managers prioritized local wins over company-wide performance.

What They Did:

Linked branch manager bonuses to a mix of individual and company-wide KPIs

Created annual strategic goal-setting sessions with managers and department heads

Empowered branches to propose their own growth initiatives—with ROI modeling

Result:

💼 Incentives fueled alignment, ownership, and strategic thinking across the organization.

✅ Step 4: Centralize Key Functions Without Losing Local Agility

The Problem: Every branch managed procurement, marketing, and pricing on its own—creating inefficiencies and pricing inconsistencies.

What They Did:

Centralized purchasing, vendor management, and pricing strategy

Retained branch-level flexibility for regional promotions and customer relationship management

Used ERP and CRM tools to standardize data, not decision-making

Result:

⚙️ Centralized scale efficiencies + localized decision-making = best of both worlds.

✅ Step 5: Review Strategy Quarterly—Not Annually

The Problem: Plans were made once a year, then forgotten or outdated.

What They Did:

Instituted quarterly strategy reviews with executive and branch leaders

Used real-time KPI dashboards to adjust tactics quickly

Created a “strategy scoreboard” that rolled up progress across all locations

Result:

📅 Plans became living tools—not static documents. Execution became part of the culture.

📈 12-Month Performance Snapshot

KPIBefore Strategic Plan12 Months Later

Average Gross Margin22.6%26.1%

Order Fill Rate86%94%

On-Time Delivery78%92%

Inventory Turn Ratio5.46.9

Branch Profitability (5 of 9)3 profitable8 profitable

🧠 Key Lessons for Multi-Location Distributors

Strategy must be local and corporate. Empower branches, but align them.

KPIs create clarity. You can’t scale what you can’t measure.

Quarterly reviews matter more than annual plans. Execution lives in real time.

Incentives drive alignment. Tie rewards to what matters most.

A single platform builds consistency. Shared systems = shared success.

🧱 Conclusion: Strategy Is the Foundation for Sustainable Scaling

IronGate Supply’s story proves that multi-location success isn’t about opening more branches—it’s about running them with intention, discipline, and shared purpose. With the right strategic planning framework, distributors can grow faster, perform better, and unify teams without sacrificing agility.


Book A Demo